Crypto History
Prehistory
- Lots of interesting stuff here that nobody talks about
- Digital Monetary Trust: Private, anonymous, digital bank
- eGold
- Liberty Trust
2009 - Bitcoin
- Bitcoin launches and is the only cryptocurrency for a while
2011 - Early Altcoins
- Pure clones of bitcoin with a few parameters tweaked
- Changed supply, difficulty adjustment, PoW algorithm
- Big lesson was that Bitcoin gets all these things mostly right, no strong advantage to changing them
- A few projects tried to do something different and interesting, e.g., namecoin
- I would actually include Ethereum in this latter category, however Ethereum has problems
2017 - ICO Boom
- In the early altcoin period, launching a coin was relatively hard, because you had to deploy software to computer and get other people to run it
- With Ethereum, you could just write an ERC20 contract and deploy it to Ethereum, so technical bar was very low
- Ethereum normalized tokens, premines, and presales, so community couldn't fundamentally reject zero-value cash grabs
2020 - DeFi and NFTs
- DeFi is basically repackaging of ponzi scheme economics
- Huge NFT bubble as people overestimate what NFTs can do and what they'll become
Crypto Psychological Archetypes
- Grifters: Incentivized to lie, hype, and overestimate what their projects can do
- Astronauts: Underestimate technical complexity, assume all problems can be solved
- Vitalik is an astronaut par excellence. People in this group underestimate need for security, simplicity, aligned incentives
- Probably enthusiastic about complex large-scale social and economic interventions. Remind me of fringe political and economic theorists
- Worst example is economic space agency
- The hoi polloi:
- Unit bias (Bitcoin is too expensive!)
- FOMB: fear that they missed the boat with bitcoin, must find new boat no matter how shitty
- Zero technical understanding, ingest radical bullshit from grifters and astronauts alike
- Think bitcoin is a prototype. No, bitcoin is like the internet, has problems but better to just deal with them
What's wrong with…?
Ethereum
- Solidity has terrible semantics
- Terrible and insecure code, even in major projects, nobody actually audits contracts
- Scaling comedy: State channels, plasma, plasma cash, sharding, roll ups. No good scaling story. Everything they're pursuing comes with massive costs.
- Massive premime. Fine during PoW, leads to massive centralization post PoS transition
- Security comedy: Solidity is phenomenally bad, everything big gets hacked, see rekt.news
- Optimism has no fraud proofs yet has $X TVL
- Community tolerates tokenization, so everything gets tokenized. Their lighting competitor got tokenized. This is serious karmic rot that infects everything.
DeFi
- Almost all ponzi economics
- No value creation
- No underlying economic activity, all finance
- Can't create credit, can only do collateralized lending, so can't serve most useful credit creation function
- Insanely complex and insecure
Stable Coins
- Actually often pretty high utility. People who want digital dollars can't access them
- Algorithmic stablecoins are doomed
- Best case scenario is digital, private, fully-collateralized bank on crypto rails
Solana
- Wildly centralized
- Insanely complex
- Terrible incentives: Couldn't resist big blockers in same way bitcoin did
- Insane costs to running a full node
NFTs
- Most contracts are fully centralized
- Contents are fully centralized, just point to some server somewhere
- Nobody audits, so each is a special snowflake complexity
- Massive overestimate of how useful NFTs are or what they'll become
- Nothing actually wrong with making digital baubles and selling them
Cardano
- Had a plane ride next to highly technical Cardano guy, very nice, very smart
- Fully just following incentives
- Technicals are terrible
Proof of Stake
- Stake ratchet: Strong centralization pressure
- Merges token holders and miners, in bitcoin these are separate groups who keep each other in check
Monero
- Relatively non-awful. Fair launch, community driven.
- Hard forks mean developers have a lot of power
- Has on-chain privacy, but transactions are 8x larger than bitcoin, so 1/8 transaction throughput
- Lighting is the way for privacy. Use lightning network to mix your coins. Make big channel with tainted coins, pay someone for inbound liquidity w/lightning, slosh your coins over to channel w/inbound liquidity, close back to BTC.
Grin
- Fair launch privacy coin with interesting tech
- Absolutely dead in the water because no VC marketing budget
zcash
- Centralized, blocks just give money to core devs.
- Moon math led to inflation bug. Probably not exploited, but no way to know.
Urbit
- Urbit's okay
- Some technical problems that make me worried
- Noble effort to decentralize social media